1. Catalogs
  2. Atomic Aquatics
  3. SCUBALAB REVIEWED Backup Breathers

SCUBALAB REVIEWED Backup Breathers

SCUBALAB REVIEWED Backup Breathers

SCUBALAB REVIEWED Backup Breathers

Product catalog summary
Overview: This document reviews alternate inflator regulators, which integrate a BC power inflator with a backup regulator, emphasizing their performance in air-sharing scenarios. The aim is to simplify diving equipment while ensuring reliable performance during emergencies.
Testing Methodology: Inflator regulators from major manufacturers were tested at Dive Lab in Panama City, Florida, using an ANSTI breathing simulator to assess breathing resistance at various depths and rates. Additionally, ergonomic tests were conducted with recreational divers off Catalina Island, California.
Key Findings: All models tested performed adequately at recreational dive depths, with notable differences under extreme conditions. The Atomic Aquatics SS1 Stainless was distinguished for its superior performance, receiving the Testers’ Choice award.
Product Reviews:
  • Atomic Aquatics SS1 Stainless: Praised for excellent breathing performance and user controls, compact and durable with a Seat Saving Orifice. Price: $249 (stainless-steel), $370 (titanium).
  • Dive Rite Rite Source: Compact with a complete hose assembly, rated Very Good in ergonomic tests. Price: $199.
  • H2Odyssey Inflator Plus: Offers good performance at a lower price, similar to Rite Source. Price: $127; $148 with hose assembly.
  • Scubapro AIR 2: Known for its compact design and ease of use, remains a popular choice. Price: $215.
  • Sherwood Scuba Gemini: Offers excellent breathing performance and control features, recommended as Best Buy. Price: $200.
  • TUSA Duo-Air IR-3: Proven performer with smooth and dry breathing. Price: $220.
  • Zeagle Octo-Z: Compact with innovative features, performs well under extreme conditions. Price: $198.
Recommendations:
  • Ensure the corrugated hose is long enough for full movement.
  • Practice ascent control techniques with a dive instructor.
  • Regularly clean and maintain the inflator reg according to manufacturer guidelines.
Alternate Inflator Regulators Overview: This guide covers alternate inflator regulators, focusing on protection, servicing, and performance testing. Key manufacturers include Atomic Aquatics, Dive Rite, H2Odyssey, Scubapro, Sherwood Scuba, TUSA, and Zeagle Systems, with prices ranging from $127 to $370. Most products offer a limited lifetime warranty and are manufactured in the USA, Taiwan, or Italy.
Protection and Maintenance: To maintain optimal performance, protect the low-pressure seat and inflator valve from contaminants like sand and salt. Regular servicing is advised, treating the inflator regulator with the same care as a traditional regulator.
Performance Testing: The ANSTI Breathing Simulator evaluates the work of breathing (WOB) for each regulator, with tests conducted at various Respiratory Minute Volumes (RMV) and depths. Performance is rated on a scale from 1 (Poor) to 5 (Excellent), with emphasis on columns A and B for recreational use conditions.
Ergonomic Testing: Besides machine testing, ergonomic traits are assessed by test divers who rate ease of breathing, dryness, ease of clearing, and user controls, which are crucial for comfort and efficiency during dives.
Travel and Dive Destinations: The document briefly mentions popular dive destinations such as Papua New Guinea, Tanzania, and Nassau, Bahamas, offering insights into travel logistics and local dive services.
See more

Catalog excerpts

SCUBALAB REVIEWED Backup Breathers -1

GET MORE For more information and charts on the alternate inflator regs tested in this issue, turn to In Depth, page 90, section 3. ALTERNATE INFLATOR REGULATORS THAT STREAMLINE YOUR When divers choose an alternate inflator regu- lator, it's often with the thought of streamlin- ing their gear, a laudable goal. What they may overlook is how well the combination of a BC power inflator and backup regulator performs all its critical functions when you need it most— an unplanned air-sharing situation. As a backup breather, your inflator reg's breathing performance should be a prime consideration. After all, standard practice with these units is to hand your primary reg off to the diver in need while you switch to the back- up. As with any air-sharing situation, you wil also need to abort the dive by making a safe, controlled ascent, so the second thing to con- sider is how well the inflator reg allows you to control buoyancy both in normal circumstances and when you are breathing from it. Good news: Our most recent test of alter- nate inflator regs (or octo-inflators as they are often called) shows that all of the following models can be counted on to perform at rec- reational dive depths and breathing rates. But we also found distinct differences, including two inflator regs that could handle the most extreme breathing tests we threw at them.

 Open the catalog to page 1
SCUBALAB REVIEWED Backup Breathers -2

We invited all major manufacturers to submit their inflator regs for this review. After making sure all of the units were working properly, we headed to Panama City, Fla., and Dive Lab, an independent testing facility. We put the units on an ANSTI breathing simulator to measure their breathing resistance, or work of breathing (WOB). Each reg was subjected to a moder- ately high breathing rate (37.5 RMV) at depths of 132 feet and 165 feet. Then we cranked up the breathing rate to an extreme level (62.5 RMV), in order to see how much reserve capac- ity the regs had. To ensure an even playing field,...

 Open the catalog to page 2
SCUBALAB REVIEWED Backup Breathers -3

FEATURES: The Gemini is a new star among alternate inflator regs thanks to a combination of* easy-breathing performance and well-designed controls. The slim, oval profile has a sizeable yellow^ deflate button anda smaller round inflate button for touch recognition. The lightweight composite housing is fitted with a standard-size mouthpiece that is replaceable. It's also nitrox-ready for mixes PERFORMANCE: According to both test divers and the ANSTI machine, this octo-inflator provided some of the best breathing performance among the regs in this review. "This is a very easy breather, as good...

 Open the catalog to page 3
SCUBALAB REVIEWED Backup Breathers -4

ERNATE INFLATOR REGULATORS Inflator Regulators »ANSTI BREATHING SIMULATOR The ANSTI machine is the international industry standard for scientifically evaluating a regu- lator's performance. It measures a regulator's work of breathing (WOB) in joules per liter (j/l) for each complete inhale/exhale cycle. We test alternate inflator regulators at four dif- ferent RMV/depth combinations (RMV stands for Respiratory Minute Volumes, basically the amount of gas that can be ventilated through the lungs in one minute). All simulator tests are performed at a supply pressure of 725-760 psi. If a regulator...

 Open the catalog to page 4
*Prices are pre-tax. They exclude delivery charges and customs duties and do not include additional charges for installation or activation options. Prices are indicative only and may vary by country, with changes to the cost of raw materials and exchange rates.